Fracture Strength of Three-Unit Implant Supported Fixed Partial Dentures with Excessive Crown Height Fabricated from Different Materials
Objectives: Fracture strength is an important factor influencing the clinical long-term success of implant-supported prostheses especially in high stress situations like excessive crown height space (CHS). The purpose of this study was to compare the fracture strength of implant-supported fixed partial dentures (FPDs) with excessive crown height, fabricated from three different materials.
Materials and Methods: Two implants with corresponding abutments were mounted in a metal model that simulated mandibular second premolar and second molar. Thirty 3-unit frameworks with supportive anatomical design were fabricated using zirconia, nickel-chromium alloy (Ni-Cr), and polyetheretherketone (PEEK) (n=10). After veneering, the CHS was equal to 15mm. Then; samples were axially loaded on the center of pontics until fracture in a universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. The failure load data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA and Games-Howell tests at significance level of 0.05.
Results: The mean failure loads for zirconia, Ni-Cr and PEEK restorations were 2086±362N, 5591±1200N and 1430±262N, respectively. There were significant differences in the mean failure loads of the three groups (P<0.001). The fracture modes in zirconia, metal ceramic and PEEK restorations were cohesive, mixed and adhesive type, respectively.
Conclusions: According to the findings of this study, all implant supported three-unit FPDs fabricated of zirconia, metal ceramic and PEEK materials are capable to withstand bite force (even para-functions) in the molar region with excessive CHS.
- Bacchi A, Consani RL, Mesquita MF, dos Santos MB. Stress distribution in fixed-partial prosthesis and peri-implant bone tissue with different framework materials and vertical misfit levels: a three-dimensional finite element analysis. J Oral Sci. 2013;55(3):239-44.
- Bacchi A, Consani RL, Mesquita MF, Dos Santos MB. Effect of framework material and vertical misfit on stress distribution in implant-supported partial prosthesis under load application: 3-D finite element analysis. Acta Odontol Scand. 2013 Sep;71(5):1243-9.
- Meriç G, Erkmen E, Kurt A, Tunç Y, Eser A. Influence of prosthesis type and material on the stress distribution in bone around implants: A 3-dimensional finite element analysis. Journal of Dental Sciences. 2011 Mar;6(1):25-32.
- Mish C. Force factors related to pationt conditions. In: Mish C, editor. Dental implant prosthetics. 2 ed., St. Louis, Mosby, 2015:206-30.
- Gehrke SA. Importance of Crown Height Ratios in Dental Implants on the Fracture Strength of Different Connection Designs: An In Vitro Study. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res. 2015 Aug;17(4):790-7.
- Rismanchian M, Shafiei S, Nourbakhshian F, Davoudi A. Flexural strengths of implant-supported zirconia based bridges in posterior regions. J Adv Prosthodont. 2014 Oct;6(5):346-50.
- Sundh A, Molin M, Sjogren G. Fracture resistance of yttrium oxide partially-stabilized zirconia all-ceramic bridges after veneering and mechanical fatigue testing. Dent Mater. 2005 May;21(5):476-82.
- Oyague RC, Sanchez-Turrion A, Lopez-Lozano JF, Suarez-Garcia MJ. Vertical discrepancy and microleakage of laser-sintered and vacuum-cast implant-supported structures luted with different cement types. J Dent. 2012 Feb;40(2):123-30.
- Chandrashekar S, Savadi R, Dayalan M, Prashanth Reddy G. A comparitive evaluation of the marginal adaptation of zirconium coping and nickel-chromium coping using shoulder finish line design: an invitro study. J Indian Prosthodont Soc. 2012 Dec;12(4):248-51.
- Erkmen E, Meric G, Kurt A, Tunc Y, Eser A. Biomechanical comparison of implant retained fixed partial dentures with fiber reinforced composite versus conventional metal frameworks: a 3D FEA study. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. 2011 Jan;4(1):107-16.
- . Kokubo Y, Tsumita M, Sakurai S, Torizuka K, Vult von Steyern P, Fukushima S. The effect of core framework designs on the fracture loads of all-ceramic fixed partial dentures on posterior implants. J Oral Rehabil. 2007 Jul;34(7):503-7.
- . Zhou L, Qian Y, Zhu Y, Liu H, Gan K, Guo J. The effect of different surface treatments on the bond strength of PEEK composite materials. Dent Mater. 2014 Aug;30(8):e209-15.
- Tardif X, Pignon B, Boyard N, Schmelzer JWP, Sobotka V, Delaunay D, et al. Experimental study of crystallization of PolyEtherEtherKetone (PEEK) over a large temperature range using a nano-calorimeter. Polym Test 2014 Jun;36:10-9.
- Siewert B, Parra M. A new group of materials in dentistry. Z Zahnärztl Implantol. 2013;29:148-59.
- Chitmongkolsuk S, Heydecke G, Stappert C, Strub JR. Fracture strength of all-ceramic lithium disilicate and porcelain-fused-to-metal bridges for molar replacement after dynamic loading. Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent. 2002 Mar;10(1):15-22.
- Helkimo E, Carlsson GE, Helkimo M. Bite force and state of dentition. Acta Odontol Scand. 1977;35(6):297-303.
- Waltimo A, Kononen M. A novel bite force recorder and maximal isometric bite force values for healthy young adults. Scand J Dent Res. 1993 Jun;101(3):171-5.
- Plengsombut K, Brewer JD, Monaco EA Jr,Davis EL. Effect of two connector designs on the fracture resistance of all-ceramic core materials for fixed dental prostheses. J Prosthet Dent. 2009 Mar;101(3):166-73.
- Senyilmaz DP, Canay S, Heydecke G, Strub JR. Influence of thermomechanical fatigue loading on the fracture resistance of all-ceramic posterior crowns. Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent. 2010 Jun;18(2):50-4.
- Sundh A, Sjogren G. Fracture resistance of all-ceramic zirconia bridges with differing phase stabilizers and quality of sintering. Dent Mater. 2006 Aug;22(8):778-84.
- Att W, Grigoriadou M, Strub JR. ZrO2 three-unit fixed partial dentures: comparison of failure load before and after exposure to a mastication simulator. J Oral Rehabil. 2007 Apr;34(4):282-90.
- Att W, Stamouli K, Gerds T, Strub JR. Fracture resistance of different zirconium dioxide three-unit all-ceramic fixed partial dentures. Acta Odontol Scand. 2007 Feb;65(1):14-21.
- Filser F, Kocher P, Weibel F, Luthy H, Scharer P, Gauckler LJ. Reliability and strength of all-ceramic dental restorations fabricated by direct ceramic
machining (DCM). Int J Comput Dent. 2001 Apr;4(2):89-106.
- Hallmann L, Mehlb A, Serenoc N, Hämmerle CH. The improvement of adhesive properties of PEEK through different pre-treatments. Appl. Surf. Sci. 2012 Jul;258(18):7213‐8.
- Noiset O, Schneider YJ, Marchand-Brynaert J. Adhesion and growth of CaCo2 cells on surface-modified PEEK substrata. J Biomater Sci Polym Ed. 2000;11(7):767-86.
- Schmidlin PR, Stawarczyk B, Wieland M, Attin T, Hammerle CH, Fischer J. Effect of different surface pre-treatments and luting materials on shear bond strength to PEEK. Dent Mater. 2010 Jun;26(6):553-9.
- Kern M, Lehmann F. Influence of surface conditioning on bonding to polyetheretherketon (PEEK). Dent Mater. 2012 Dec;28(12):1280-3.
- Stawarczyk B, Beuer F, Wimmer T, Jahn D, Sener B, Roos M, et al. Polyetheretherketone-a suitable material for fixed dental prostheses? J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater. 2013 oct;101(7):1209-16.